Carrie Culberson goes to have dinner with Vincent Doan & he allegedly stops the vehicle on Hunt Road, and gets a gun out of the trunk, returns to the driver’s seat and holds Carrie there for 4 ˝ - 5 hours. Vincent Doan would later call the residence of Carrie Culberson to inquire about her coming over later. When she said she would not be coming over, Doan allegedly stated that if she didn’t’ he would come over and kill her and her whole family. – Tonya Whitten’s Testimony – State’s Witness – Ohio V. Doan
Tuesday, August 27, 1996
Carrie Culberson enters the Total Image Tanning Salon/Gym & confides in Tonya Whitten (States Witness, Ohio v. Doan), that she and Mr. Doan had an alleged incident the day before on Hunt Rd. Carrie then went into the tanning room. Vincent Doan allegedly called the tanning salon asking for Carrie. Tonya Whitten took the phone to the room. Moments later Doan shows up @ the salon. He says to Whitten, “I don’t understand why the fuckin’ bitch needs to tan, we laid out in the sun all day Sunday”, look, I’m still burned”. Carrie goes outside with Doan and then they later leave separately. Tonya Whitten’s Testimony – State’s Witness – Ohio V. Doan
9:00-9:30 p.m. – Vincent Doan allegedly confronts Carrie Culberson once again outside the Rolling Hills bar in Marathon that she is attending with friends after the volleyball game. He is seen drive erratically out of the bar’s parking lot by friends of Carrie Culberson, in his black Ford Mustang. The vehicle has a loud engine that is distinct so they knew when Doan left. Testimony of State’s Witnesses – T. Whitten, C. Kukuk & Jessica Williams (Ohio v. Doan)
11:00 p.m. – 11:15 Carrie Culberson requests that Cicely Kukuk drive by Vincent Doan’s residence before and after she drops off Tonya & Brian Whitten. Both times Mr. Doan’s Mustang was in front of his residence. (Testimony of State’s Witness – Cicely Kukuk – Ohio V. Doan)
11:30 p.m. – Carrie Culberson is dropped off at her residence on 127 Bourbon Street. . (Testimony of State’s Witness – Cicely Kukuk – Ohio V. Doan)
11:30 – 11:40 – Kim Lannard sees the Red Honda CRX drive slowly up Bourbon Street before turning on the lights. Kim Lannard lives on the same street as Carrie on 136 Bourbon Street. Carrie Culberson has no curfew and she’s 22 years old, she would not need to sneak to leave to go anywhere. Was this the exact moment she was taken by “someone” waiting for her upon her arrival home? Vincent Doan’s residence is only three blocks away. No vehicle would be needed to get from his residence to hers IF it were Doan. (Testimony of State’s Witness Kim Lannard – Ohio V. Doan)
By the time Ms. Brown gets back to the kitchen window, she only hears tires squealing. No sign of Vincent Doan, Carrie Culberson, or the Red Honda CRX that was in the driveway on Wright Street.
1:00 a.m. – Vincent Doan allegedly knocks on the window of Jeff & Jennifer Warren. He uses the telephone there by making a collect call to his father, Lawrence Baker. He states that the truck he is driving is out of gas and the pay phone down the street is out-of-order. (State’s Witness Ohio V. Doan)
3:15 a.m. – Lori Baker, the ex-wife of Tracey Baker (Vincent’s half-brother), allegedly witnesses Vincent Doan at the back door of their Supringer St. residence, waiting for someone to answer the door. Baker testifies that Vincent Doan was wearing no shirt, no shoes, or socks. Vincent Doan was wearing only a pair of blue jeans, and there was smeared blood on his arms, chest, and pants. She is able to see Mr. Doan standing at the back door through a bedroom window and the motion censor light is on shining directly onto Mr. Doan. (State’s Witness, Ohio V. Doan)
3:15 a.m. – Vicki Watkins, twin sister of Lori Baker, is also awoken by a knock on the door. She allegedly looks out the window of her niece, Jacqueline Baker’s bedroom and saw Vincent Doan standing waiting for someone to answer the door. She stated she knew it was Doan because of the tattoo that was on his left shoulder, of a grim reaper. She also stated that Doan appeared to be dirty, and that he only was wearing blue jeans. Watkins never emerges from the bedroom because she is NOT supposed to be spending the night at Lori’s house. Tracey Baker does not know she’s there. Tracey arrived home after she and the children were in bed. (State’s Witness, Ohio V. Doan)
